Skip to content
GTA666
intermediate9 min readUpdated 2026-09-09

Rules, Applications and Whitelisting

Write a rulebook people actually read, build an application form that filters, and run Discord verification and bans without wrecking your community.

Quick answer

A rulebook exists to make staff decisions predictable, not to cover every situation. Keep it short, define your terms, and write down the punishment ladder before you need it. Whitelisting through a Discord-linked application is the single most effective quality filter available to a roleplay server, and costs you reach in exchange.

Rules are not there to make your server strict. They are there so that two different staff members, on different nights, reach the same decision about the same incident. That is the whole job. Everything else — the tone, the length, the numbered subsections — is decoration.

This chapter assumes the FiveM/GTA V roleplay ecosystem, where these conventions were built. Private-server support for GTA 6 has not been announced, but rulebooks are social technology, not code: if a GTA 6 platform ever appears, this is the part that will carry over unchanged.

Start from what every server already shares

Most of your rulebook already exists. The core roleplay rules — no random deathmatch, no vehicle deathmatch, value your life, don’t metagame, don’t powergame, stay in character — are near-universal across servers, and your players will arrive already knowing them. They are covered in detail in the rules every server shares.

Your job is not to reinvent them. It is to:

  1. Define them in your own words, so there is no ambiguity about what your server means by “value your life”.
  2. Add the handful of rules specific to you — your gang policy, your robbery cooldowns, your rules about streaming or recording.
  3. State the consequences.

Writing rules people can be judged against

A rule is only useful if a staff member can decide, in ninety seconds, whether it was broken. Test each one against that.

Bad: “Don’t ruin other people’s roleplay.” Better: “Do not kill another player without a clear in-character reason established before the shot. If you cannot explain your character’s motive to a staff member, it is RDM.”

Practical drafting rules:

  • Define your terms once, at the top. RDM, VDM, metagaming, powergaming, NVL, fear RP, combat logging, new-life rule. Half of all rule arguments are definition arguments.
  • Number them. Staff need to cite 3.2 in a ban reason.
  • Keep them enforceable with the tools you have. txAdmin’s player manager handles warnings, bans and a whitelist, and logs every admin action — write rules whose consequences you can actually apply and evidence.
  • Say what is allowed, not only what is banned. “Robberies require at least three police online” is clearer than “don’t rob when police are low”.
  • Put the timers in a table. Cooldowns, revive timers, new-life memory loss.
  • Keep the player-facing document to one page. Put the edge cases, precedents and punishment ladder in a separate staff handbook.

The punishment ladder

Write it before you need it, because the first time you need it you will be angry.

A workable default:

Severity Example Outcome
Minor Breaking character in chat, minor NVL Verbal warning, logged
Moderate RDM on one player, powergaming Formal warning, then 1–3 day ban
Serious Repeated RDM, harassment in Discord 7–30 day ban
Severe Cheating, exploiting, real-money trading Permanent, no appeal for 6 months
Non-negotiable Real-world threats, doxxing, anything illegal Permanent, reported, and removed from Discord

Two principles keep this fair. Log everything — every warning, in a searchable place, so a “first offence” claim can be checked. And decouple the decision from the mood: serious bans get a second staff member’s sign-off. More on that in staff and moderation.

The application form

An application is a filter, and what it filters is effort. That is its real value — people unwilling to spend twenty minutes on a form are the people who will not read your rules either.

A form that works:

  • Age and timezone. Set a minimum age and enforce it.
  • Roleplay experience, honestly answered — including “none”, which should not disqualify anyone.
  • Two or three rule scenarios. “You are shot at from a moving car and survive. What does your character do for the next thirty minutes, and why?” These reveal understanding far better than “what is RDM?”, which is Googleable.
  • A character backstory, 150–300 words. Length-capped, because a wall of text is not a better answer.
  • Their Discord tag and their in-game identifier.

Avoid: multiple-choice rule quizzes (answers get shared within a day), and forms so long you cannot keep up with reviewing them. If your backlog exceeds a week, applicants go and join someone else.

Interviews are the tier above. A ten-minute voice chat filters better than any form and costs you a staff member’s evening. Reserve them for servers where the standard justifies it.

Discord verification and identity

Link Discord to the game. It is the closest thing you have to a durable identity.

Why it matters: names change, a player can appear under a different in-game handle, and a ban on one identifier alone is easy to slip. Tying an account to a Discord ID means your whitelist, your roles and your ban list all point at the same person.

The standard pattern:

  1. Player joins the Discord and passes a verification step.
  2. They submit the application; on acceptance they receive a Whitelisted role.
  3. The server checks that role, or a linked identifier list, on connect.
  4. Staff roles in Discord mirror staff permissions in txAdmin — see staff and moderation.

Bans should be issued against multiple identifiers, not just one, and mirrored into Discord. A player banned from the game but still active in your Discord will keep the drama alive.

Appeals

Every ban policy needs a documented exit, for one selfish reason: without it, every ban becomes a public argument in your general channel.

  • One channel or form for appeals, and nowhere else.
  • A stated waiting period before an appeal is accepted (72 hours is common, and cools people down).
  • The banning staff member does not decide the appeal.
  • A published outcome format: upheld, reduced, or overturned, with a one-line reason.

Overturning a ban publicly, occasionally, when your staff got it wrong, does more for your reputation than any amount of marketing.

Checklist before you open applications

  • One-page player rulebook, terms defined, rules numbered.
  • Separate staff handbook with the punishment ladder.
  • Application form live, with a named person responsible for the queue.
  • Discord verification working, Whitelisted role created.
  • Appeal channel and appeal policy published.
  • Logging in place so warnings can be looked up.

With rules and a whitelist in place, the next question is who enforces them, and how you stop that power being abused: staff and moderation.

Takeaways
  • Short, enforceable rules beat a long list nobody finishes reading
  • Define your terms — RDM, VDM, powergaming, NVL — or every ruling becomes an argument
  • Whitelisting trades player numbers for player quality; pick deliberately
  • Link Discord accounts so identity survives a name change or a new game licence
  • Write the punishment ladder and the appeal route before your first ban

Frequently asked

Should my server be whitelisted?

If you want serious roleplay, yes. An application filters out people who will not read anything, which is most of the trouble. The cost is real: whitelisting caps your growth rate and gives you a permanent backlog of applications to review. Many servers run an open server plus a whitelisted one.

How long should the rulebook be?

Short enough that a new player finishes it. Aim for one page of principles and definitions, with a separate longer document for staff covering edge cases and the punishment ladder. Nobody reads the fifteen-page version, including your staff.

Are permanent bans a good idea?

Reserve them for cheating, real-world harassment, and anything illegal. For roleplay mistakes, temporary bans plus a clear appeal route recover more players than they lose. A community that never lets anyone back shrinks by design.

Sources
  1. Server commands · Cfx.re
  2. txAdmin · Cfx.re
  3. Roleplay Community Update · Rockstar Games
Day-one whitelist

Get recruited when GTA 6 private servers open.